What We Can't Teach: Courage and Commitment in Campaigns
We teach and train people to do lots of things: build strong online programs; measure the reach and effectiveness of every email and every tweet; set goals and metrics, then strategize with all the data those metrics create.
All of these parts and more are critical to running ambitious, effective campaigns that engage others to win. But at the end of the day they're just the engine.
The longer I organize, the more I learn that the engine just isn't enough. In the last few years, I've come to believe that the fuel it takes to drive the engine, the two factors most critical to great campaigns, are things we absolutely cannot teach: Courage and Commitment.
No fuel, no forward progress. And no amount of planning, data analysis or training is a substitute.
WHERE DO WE FIND COURAGE?
Every change maker I've ever met has a story about when he or she first stood up for something that really mattered. When was it for you?
For me it was my senior year in college. I grew up on a potato farm in Caribou, Maine. My family went bankrupt in the early 1990s when Idaho industrial farms took over the potato market from small family farms like ours. Fortunately for me Bowdoin College, a rather upscale liberal arts school in Maine, didn't look at my parents' income. They accepted me then supported me with a significant scholarship. My first day on campus I felt both grateful to have the opportunity to go to a school like Bowdoin, and humbled by the beat-up Horizon hatchback with my grandmother's rocking chair tied to the top that my parents parked in the line of Audis and Volvos.
My entire life I had been painfully shy, really to the point that I didn't speak at all in classes my first three years of college. My worst fear was (still is) public speaking. But early in my senior year Mario Cuomo came to speak on campus. It was the first time I had ever heard anyone at Bowdoin speak publicly to a large gathering about unequal our economy is, how much a threat that inequality is to our democracy, and about the government's role in addressing that inequality. A few days later, another student, Wystan A., wrote an editorial in the student paper. He tried to undermine everything Mario Cuomo had argued for, making anyone who ever depended on government help seem unworthy, un-American even. After reading his editorial, I went back to my room and furiously started writing a letter to the Editor, letting Wystan know that I was one such unworthy person, whose parents had depended on the help of the government in their moment of deepest shame and despair.
Wystan's letter had stirred in me the most visceral sense of indignity. Not an ideological, self-righteous anger, but a real grief from remembering how very hard my parents worked to try to get by, how desperately they tried to avoid depending on government assistance, and how feeble they felt when it became the only option. In my letter I wrote about what it was like growing up in
a family that weighed putting oil in the furnace in a cold Maine winter against paying the grocery store tab so we could keep getting food. I wrote about what it was like to have the privilege of living at a college where the average student drove a car worth more than my parents' annual income.
In a moment of absolute fury at the world as it was, I hit "send."
I quickly realized I had just outed myself as white trash at one of the ritziest schools in the country. (In retrospect the fluorescent pink t-shirts and mall hair probably gave it away long before.)
I was absolutely terrified.
But a few days later, when the letter ran in the student paper, other people like me started coming out of the woodwork. Soon, other scholarship students, professors who wanted to do something to help, staff who served us food and answered phones, and other students who were just curious started asking me "What can we do?" and "What should we do?" We formed a team and launched a year-long effort to save need-blind admissions at Bowdoin (so that the Admissions department would never decide whether or not to admit a prospective student based on their parents' income). We organized to get first-generation college students and low-income students to speak up in class and participate as full campus citizens. And we launched a "conversation about class" at a school that really hadn't talked about class in any public way to that point. Over the years since then, Bowdoin has developed one of the most progressive financial aid programs in the country. This is certainly not just because I decided one night to write a letter. But our organizing that year was a piece of the puzzle that I'd like to believe helped move the campus just a few steps forward on this issue.
SO WHAT IS COURAGE?
Maybe it's easier first to say what it's not. It's not judgment of others. It's not wishful thinking about "sustainable" or "systemic" change-there is nothing sustainable about change. It's not ideology. It's certainly not conditional on having a perfect "power map." And it's not simply a rush to righteous action. I am honestly worn down and demoralized daily by how many campaigns I see that are founded on these conditions, mindlessly dependent on these things.
Perfect plan? (Photo licensed through Creative Commons, courtesy of torres21)I am also fatigued by campaign leaders I meet who are searching indefinitely for the perfect plan to which they can commit, coming back month after month with some revised version of their plan with little action at all in the interim. News flash: there is never a perfect campaign plan worth committing to. The world is chaotic and unpredictable. There is only the courage to commit to a change worth fighting for, the urgency to create enough of a plan that such courage is actionable in the real world in a purposeful way, and the humility to invite others to join us in action, and ask that they help us figure it out as we go.
Courage is not being "empowered" by someone else. When I sat in my bedroom writing a letter that night, no one was there empowering me. There were many afterwards who joined with me as peers, though. None of us have the ability to empower anyone else. We can, however act with courage on what we think is right, invite others to join us, and share responsibility for winning change.
Courage is not about crafting campaigns that will ask less of people. Courage doesn't pander to people by pretending they don't know what power is and how it works in the world, as if one click or one rally could win everything. That's the opposite of courage. And, truth be told, the opposite of respect and dignity. Courage is having the respect to ask much, much more of ourselves and of each other. Courage is launching into fights that seem all but impossible when we start. Courage is being very transparent about the remarkable odds we're up against, and trusting that others can find the courage in themselves to stand up despite those odds.
Courage is the emotion that precedes all action, the feeling that comes before all planning. It's grounded in a deep insufferable grief, based in our own, our friends' and our families' real life experiences, not founded in some academic theory or ideology about the way the world should work.
Courage is, in essence, the insatiable quest for human dignity that derives from the deepest, most desperate sense of real despair with the way things are.
WHAT DOES COURAGE LOOK LIKE?
The thing about courage is that we know it when we see it. Courage is like a virus, an infection of dignity. We all learn at some point in our lives how it feels to be fiercely afraid and to act in spite of that fear. We know what courage feels like in the way our stomachs turn over and chills run through our limbs. So when we see someone else act in that way, it engages the same feeling in us.
We can recognize courage in small actions, like the first actions most of us took when we started organizing.

We can recognize courage in larger actions, like those of Juan Rodriguez and his 3 undocumented friends setting out on a 4-month Trail of Dreams, walking from Miami to Washington, DC last year. For these brilliant undocumented students whose parents brought them to the US as children, the only options after graduating high school were returning to a country they never knew, living with no hope in the only country they have known, or standing up to try and win the impossible-a chance at life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Instead of settling for the occasional day of action, Juan and his fellow walkers committed to engage new people, build real relationships, talk with parents, students, teachers along their journey, and, with courage and dignity, reached out to police and sheriffs in unfriendly towns along their trail.
A few times in every generation we witness courage in extraordinary actions, like those of Egyptian protesters this month. Over the course of the protests I kept re-watching these videos from a 26-year-old woman, Asmaa Mahfouz, because seeing her courage was the only way I could understand how so many could risk so much:
The peaceful revolution in Egypt was preceded by years of important organizing, and it is hard to believe the people of Egypt would have succeeded if the January 25th protests had simply been an impromptu mobilization. But the organizing itself was not enough, without the courage that made Asmaa and others dream of something bigger and risk everything to make it possible.
SO WHAT IS COMMITMENT?
If courage is the fuel that gets the engine going, commitment is the will to keep filling the tank, to see things through no matter how dire the situation may seem. Not that the will to see things through is simple at all. It requires attention to detail, passion for the craft of making change, and a zealous, unwavering dedication to achieving an outcome, no matter what the odds, risks, obstacles and challenges along the way.
Commitment is not asking "Is this winnable?" I actually think that question is killing our movement and I want to scrub it off flipcharts and whiteboards in every corner of the country. By choosing "winnable" fights we are winning battles and losing the war. Commitment is saying "In the face of unfathomable odds I will stick with this for as long as it takes to feel dignity in my life again, and to see dignity restored to the faces of those around me." What would have happened if the Egyptian protesters had asked "Is this winnable?" before their 18-day protest started? It would never have started!
It's the paradox of organizing that only action in the world can actually reshape the political terrain to make the impossible possible.
And what would have happened if the Egyptian protesters had organized a one-day national day of action and everyone went home? So what are we doing folks? Where are we going with all of these national days of action? Where are we going with all of these one-day nonviolent direct actions? Is it just about getting arrested? I have a natural and very healthy fear of getting arrested and would have to work up a great deal of courage to do so, so I won't be joining you anytime soon unless you're more committed than that. If you're committed, that means going back the next day, and the next, and the next. Or is it just about rallies and marches? As a chronic introvert I'd rather stay at home and read a book if you just want me to be a body, a headcount at an event. Unless, that is, I know that at the rally or march you might ask me to do something purposeful, really important for my country and the world. Ask me to take risks, to get outside my comfort zone, but not just for the sake of that alone. Ask me-then trust me-to make something real of your campaign or movement in my own community.

In recent days, the workers and allies organizing in Wisconsin have shown a great example of Courage and Commitment. They didn't wait for a perfect plan to form. The legislators acted quickly and courageously by leaving the state to prevent a catastrophic vote. Protesters rallied, filling the state capitol, taking time from work, family and personal time to show their opposition. And they've stuck with it. Despite threats, the legislators are staying away and the protesters are staying put. If they had simply protested for a day or two, there would be no outcry nationally, and no support for the legislators who are blocking the vote. Now that they've acted (and continued acting), this is the time to develop a complex game plan. If they'd watched the moment, then said, "We need a great plan before we take action," it would have been too late. The vote would have been forced, the public would barely have heard about it, and unions across the country would be threatened by similar action. But, because people had courage and commitment, they now have opportunity to launch a serious, powerful campaign, one that can spread far beyond Wisconsin to protect unions and families around the country.
WHAT CAN WE DO?
I left a pretty comfy job teaching in academia because I grew tired of critique with no answers. So here's my attempt to suggest some ways to regenerate the fuel we need for change, based on my experience of the campaigns that have demanded-and received-the most from me.
1) Pick a fight worth having. Yes, I'm talking to you. I don't care who's paying you to be an organizer, or to build a website. How are YOU personally affected by the world as it is right now? How are your own parents, friends and family directly affected? What fight seems impossible now, but totally worth getting into anyway because not acting on it is deepening your personal loss of dignity or hope or that of those you care about?
2) Invite others to join you. Not as followers. Not as pseudo-empowered leaders. As peers. Throw away the flipchart paper, clear the table, have a couple drinks, and brainstorm. What does the world look like if you take action? THINK BIG.
3) Start acting with dignity and courage. How can you craft action that will unveil your courage, inspire dignity and solidarity in others? The Trail of Dreams walkers inspired thousands not because they were protesting outside sheriff's offices, but because they went in and talked with them face to face, human to human. The protesters in Egypt inspired me as much with their collective prayers as with their flags and chants. Not because those prayers were symbolic, but because they demonstrated both shared will and shared humility about the change they were seeking.
4) Stick with it. And once you're sticking with it, then we can help you build the engine it takes to funnel your fuel, your courage and commitment, into movement.
So, what do you think?







Leave a comment